DotAsia Board Elections 2024
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FINAL DRAFT-B (clean version)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FINAL DRAFT-B (redline based on 2024 second draft with updates in anticipation of the Proposed Amendments to the DotAsia Articles of Association rejected)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FINAL DRAFT-A (clean version)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FINAL DRAFT-A (redline based on 2024 second draft)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures SECOND DRAFT-B (clean version)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures SECOND DRAFT-B (redline based on 2024 first draft with updates in anticipation of the Proposed Amendments to the DotAsia Articles of Association rejected)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures SECOND DRAFT-A (clean version)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures SECOND DRAFT-A (redline based on 2024 first draft)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FIRST DRAFT (clean version)
- DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FIRST DRAFT (redline based on 2023 final version)
The timeline for the Board Elections 2024 (including timeline for Proposed Amendments to the DotAsia Articles) is as follows:
Oct 18, 2023 | (Wed) | 1st Draft of Board Elections Procedures (BGC-004 v.2) |
Dec 28, 2023 | (Thu) | 2nd Draft of Board Elections Procedures (A&B versions) |
Feb 2, 2024 | (Fri) | Final Draft of Board Elections Procedures (A&B versions) |
Feb 27, 2024 | (Tue) | Final Board Elections Procedures |
Mar 13, 2024 | (Wed) | Seating of the Election Committee and Nomination Committee |
Mar 20, 2024 | (Wed) | Deadline for confirmation of voting representative |
Mar 21, 2024 | (Thu) | Nomination Period Begins |
Apr 9, 2024 | (Tue) | Nomination Period Ends (20 days) Dispute Resolution Period Begins if no voting necessary (96 hours) |
Apr 25, 2024 | (Thu) | Nominations Report sent to the Board |
Apr 29, 2024 | (Mon) | Voting Period Begins (if necessary) |
May 1, 2024 | (Wed) | Call for Annual General Meeting (AGM) |
May 8, 2024 | (Wed) | Voting Period Ends (10 days) Dispute Resolution Period Begins (96 hours) |
May 23, 2024 | (Thu) | Annual General Meeting 2024 New elected Board members assume office |
- Sponsor Member: 2
- Co-Sponsor Member: 2
Director | Representing | From Sub-Region |
Arthur CHANG (Resigned 2023.04.05) |
Sponsor Members | North East Asia |
Murad IBRAGIMOV (Resigned 2023.04.03) |
Sponsor Members | Central & South East Asia |
Alireza SALEH | Sponsor Members | Middle East & Western Asia |
Leonid TODOROV (Resigned 2023.04.03) |
Sponsor Members | Not in Asia Pacific |
Satish BABU | Co-Sponsor Members | N/A |
Director | Representing | From Sub-Region |
Nicole T. I. CHAN | Sponsor Members | North East Asia |
Maureen HILYARD | Sponsor Members | Australasia & Pacific |
Jordan CARTER | Sponsor Members | Australasia & Pacific |
Jose A. LAY | Sponsor Members | Central & South East Asia |
Akinori MAEMURA | Co-Sponsor Members | N/A [North East Asia] |
Upon the expiration of the term for the Directors as explained above, there will be no remaining Director coming from the following Sub-Region:
- Middle East & Western Asia
In accordance with the geographical diversity requirement specified in Article 3(4) of the DotAsia AA, the geographical diversity requirement that there shall be at least one (1) Director from at least three (3) of the four (4) sub-regions of Asia Pacific is already satisfied by the remaining Directors.
DotAsia Board Election Committee for the Board Elections 2024:
- Election Chair: Ms. Cheryl Langdon-Orr
- Election Committee Co-Sponsor Members community representative: to monitor election for seat(s) returned from the Sponsor Member category: Mr. Kuo-Wei Wu (TWIGF)
- Election Committee Sponsor Members community representative: to monitor election for seat(s) returned from the Co-Sponsor Member category: Mr. Andrew Molivurae (.vu)
DotAsia Nomination Committee for the Board Elections 2024:
- NomCom Chair: Heather Forrest
- NomCom Members: Bertrand Cherrier, Pua Hunter and Craig Ng
The term of the Election Committee and Nomination Committee for the Board Elections 2024 is from Mar 13, 2024 until the completion of the Board Elections 2024. In accordance with the Board Elections Procedures (BEP), the Election Committee will oversee the election process, declare the election results, and resolve procedural disputes, if any. The Nomination Committee will determine the eligibility of candidates, establish and enforce an Elections Code of Conduct, and nominate a person for appointment to the DotAsia Board directly.
In accordance with the BEP Section 2.2: The email address to be used for the Nominations process is elections[at]board.dot.asia. In accordance with the BEP Section 2.6 Dispute Resolution: Any complaint, disputes and appeals regarding the conduct of the election must be lodged in writing with the Election Chair to electioncommittee[at]board.dot.asia.
An Election Code of Conduct is established by the NomCom in accordance with the DotAsia Articles of Association. Any non-compliance with the Code may result in exclusion of the relevant person from the election. In accordance with Section 4.1 of the Code, if you experience, witness, or is aware of any behaviour that is inconsistent with the Code, please report the behaviour to electionconduct[at]board.dot.asia.
As specified in the Board Elections Procedures (https://dot.asia/BGC-004/), during the Nomination Period and the Voting Period, no membership status changes will be processed by DotAsia – be they new Members joining or existing Members resigning. Therefore, DotAsia will close its Register of Members from Mar 21 to Apr 9, 2024 (Nomination Period) and from Apr 29 to May 8, 2024 (Voting Period).
Election Results
Sponsor Member Category
There were 2 vacancies in the Sponsor Member category. Based on the voting results, the following candidates were elected in the Sponsor Member category:
Candidate |
Sub-Region | Term |
Boyoung KIM | North & East Asia | 3 years |
Thomas BARRETT | Not in Asia Pacific | 3 years |
Co-Sponsor Member Category
There were 2 vacancies in the Co-Sponsor Member category and the number of candidates standing for the election in the Co-Sponsor Member category is equal to the number of vacancies in that category (i.e. we have 2 candidates and 2 seats), no voting was required. In accordance with the updated DotAsia Articles of Association Section 4. Rotation of Directors, 1 Co-Sponsor candidate would serve 2 years and 1 Co-Sponsor candidate would serve 3 years. A drawing of lots was conducted by the voting system and the candidates’ term of service is stated below:
Candidate |
Sub-Region | Term |
Satish BABU | Central & South East Asia | 2 years |
Rupesh Bhakta SHRESTHA | Central & South East Asia | 3 years |
Name |
Satish BABU (Re-elected) |
Thomas BARRETT (Newly elected) |
Jordan CARTER |
Nicole T. I. CHAN |
Edmon CHUNG |
Maureen HILYARD |
Boyoung KIM (Newly elected) |
Jose A. LAY |
Akinori MAEMURA |
Rupesh Bhakta SHRESTHA (Newly elected) |
Jo-Fan YU (Newly appointed) |
Nomination Results
Candidate |
Member Category | Nominated by |
Seconded by |
Candidate Confirmation | Candidate Sub-Region |
Kashif ADEEL | Sponsor Member | PH Domain Foundation (.PH) | The IUSN Foundation (.NU) | Candidacy Accepted | Middle East and Western Asia |
Satish BABU | Co-Sponsor Member | APSIG | APNG | Candidacy Accepted | Central and South East Asia |
Thomas BARRETT | Sponsor Member | PW Registry Corp. (.PW) | auDA (.AU) | Candidacy Accepted | Not in Asia Pacific |
Boyoung KIM | Sponsor Member | KISA, KRNIC (.KR) | JPRS (.JP) | Candidacy Accepted | North and East Asia |
Rupesh Bhakta SHRESTHA | Co-Sponsor Member | SANOG | APNIC | Candidacy Accepted | Central and South East Asia |
Based on the DotAsia Board Elections Procedures 2024:
SPONSOR CATEGORY
DotAsia will enter into the voting process, which starts on April 29, 2024 (Mon), and ends on May 8, 2024 (Wed) at 23:59 UTC (i.e. 10 days), with the following 3 candidates up for election for the 2 seats in the Sponsor Member category: After voting, the 2 who receive the highest number of votes will be deemed elected.CO-SPONSOR CATEGORY
Since the number of candidates standing for the election in the Co-Sponsor Member category is equal to the number of vacancies in that category (i.e. we have 2 candidates and 2 seats), no voting would be required. Satish BABU and Rupesh Bhakta SHRESTHA are therefore deemed elected as they are the only candidates in the Co-Sponsor Member category. In accordance with the updated DotAsia Articles of Association Section 4. Rotation of Directors, 1 Co-Sponsor candidate would serve 2 years and 1 Co-Sponsor candidate would serve 3 years. A drawing of lots will be conducted by the voting system BigPulse on May 9, 2024, 00:00 UTC. The winner of the draw will serve the 3 years term of service.Candidate BIOS
Kashif ADEEL
Kashif ADEEL
Candidacy Statement | SOI While thanking ccTLD’s for nominating and seconding me for the upcoming Board elections as a Sponsor-Member’s candidate, my objectives for the second term on the DotAsia Board are the following:- As the Board Finance Committee Chair during 2021-2023, I spearheaded an effort to return the organization and its subsidiaries to profitability. We have been at a breaking point in the direction, and my 20-plus years of management experience spread across large-scale business transformation initiatives with some of the largest financial institutions in the Middle East and Pakistan allow me to suggest with much confidence that the crucial task can and should be accomplished. If elected for the new term, I will be happy to support this work.
- As a seasoned project manager, I tried to identify good operational practices at DotAasia and foster them, while working hard to improve counterproductive practices and help the staff find their bearings, particularly in the area of digital strategy and marketing. There still is a lot we should do to ensure the registry’s entrance on the path of sustained growth, and I hope to continue counseling the staff and overseeing the process.
- With my record of service as a Co-Chair for APNG, Chair for the fellowship committee for APSIG and Chair for Internet Research Community (IRC), I am not new to community projects at DotAsia and have remained very close to the regional community. We made some progress in the community project sponsorship area but we have a great chance for improving this work so that every ccTLD would be able to reap the benefits of its association with DotAasia, and I am going to remain a part of the effort.
- Last but not least, With much expertise gained over the previous tenure (2021-2023, I trust I can further contribute to the betterment of DotAsia’s institutional development and to promotion of its growth in the first place.
Candidate BIO:
Profile Summary [PDF]Thomas BARRETT
Thomas BARRETT
Candidacy Statement | SOI
I hereby submit my Candidacy Statement to serve on DotAsia’s Board.
I represent the .PW Sponsor member, as Admin Contact for the ccTLD (PW Registry Corp). I have been involved with the .PW ccTLD since 2003, when I led the IANA re-delegation with the support of the government of the Republic of Palau.
I also own two ICANN-accredited registrars: EnCirca (c.2001) and Name Share (c.2003). I am a member of the ccNSO, Intellectual Property Constituency, and Registrar Stakeholder Group within ICANN.
I am interested in helping the DotAsia registry fulfill its mission to serve the Asia internet community. I can provide global and independent insights towards helping DotAsia grow and prosper. I can also contribute deep technical, financial, and strategic expertise and experience to help ensure the success of the DotAsia organization.
I also serve as Chair of the Web3 Working Group for the Internet Committee of the International Trademark Association. This is my fifth year leading INTA’s efforts to identify new policies and regulations for protecting intellectual property on the blockchain.
I serve on ICANN’s Nominating Committee. I previously served as Chair of the Nominating Committee Review Working Group. The NomCom appoints half of the ICANN Board as well as other positions. The Review Working Group is implementing 27 recommendations, including ICANN Bylaw changes to improve the accountability and transparency of the Nominating Committee process and appointments. This is useful experience that can be applied on behalf of future DotAsia board governance.
I developed the first business class for the DNS Entrepreneurial Center in Giza, Egypt and presented SWOT ccTLD workshops in five countries including: Egypt, Oman, Qatar, UAE (Dubai), and Tunisia. I also have served on the Program Committee and Speaker for the Middle East DNS Forum since 2015.
Here is a summary of my qualifications for the DotAsia Board:
Internet and Board Governance
I have extensive internet and board governance experience, including:
- ICANN (1998-Present)
- Board member of NetBenefit Ltd, a public company on the London Stock Exchange (1999-2001)
- Founding Board member of Afilias (c.2000)
- Finance Committee member for my town (~$30 million budget)
- Ethereum Naming Service Decentralized Autonomous Organization Delegate
ICANN activities include:
- Delegate to the ICANN Nominating Committee (second consecutive year)
- Previously concluded as Chair of the Nominating Committee Review Working Group
- Names Collision Analysis Project (NCAP)
- NextGen Mentor
- GNSO Guidance Process for Applicant Support (of next gTLD Program)
Extensive TLD Registry Experience
In addition to launching the .PW Registry and being a Founding Board member of Afilias, I worked with Neustar to launch .BIZ, the second new gTLD.
Since launching EnCirca in 2001, I have served in an advisory or consulting capacity to several ccTLD and gTLD TLD Registries, including:
- I serve on the .US Stakeholder Council. Previously, I served on Neustar’s Kids.US Advisory Council
- I serve as a member of the fTLD DMARC Working Group for .BANK and .INSURANCE. Previously, I was on fTLD’s Security Standards Advisory Group
- I served on the .PHARMACY Advisory Committee (As their largest registrar)
- EnCirca is the exclusive ICANN Registrar for .POST, .CPA and .REALTOR TLDs
- EnCirca also designed and maintains the verification platform for the .POST, .BANK and .INSURANCE Registries with integration to over 30 other ICANN registrars
Deep DNS Business and Technical Knowledge
- I own two successful ICANN-Accredited Registrars
- I developed the first business class for the DNS Entrepreneurship Center in Giza, Egypt and presented SWOT ccTLD workshops in five countries including: Egypt, Oman, Qatar, UAE (Dubai), and Tunisia. (see DNS Entrepreneurship Center)
- I also have served on Program Committee and Speaker for the Middle East DNS Forum since 2015
- I have managed the involuntary bulk transfers of over sixty registrars terminated by either ICANN or TLD registries (both gTLD and ccTLD)
- Chair of the Blockchain Committee for the International Trademark Association and Advisor, DAO Delegate, or Director of several blockchain projects
Personal
- I reside in Rockport, Massachusetts, US
- Married, wife Colleen and four adult children
- Mechanical Engineer with degrees from Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MSME) and Worcester Polytechnic Institute (BSME).
- More information here: LinkedIn Profile: Thomas Barrett | LinkedIn.
If you would like to ask me any questions or schedule a personal video chat, feel free to contact me at tbarrett[at]pwregistry.pw.
Candidate BIO:
Tom Barrett is President and Founder of the .PW ccTLD registry and two ICANN-accredited domain name registrars: EnCirca, and Name Share. Tom also serves as Chair of the Blockchain Committee for the International Trademark Association and recently launched Altroots, a brand protection service for blockchain domains.
EnCirca specializes in partnering with top-level domain registry operators, including serving as exclusive registrar for .CPA and .REALTOR, and designing and maintaining the verification platform for the .BANK and .INSURANCE registries. EnCirca also provides registration, custody backup and trademark protection services for blockchain-based domain name projects.
Previously, Tom helped launch ICANN’s first two new gTLDS while at Neustar (.BIZ) and NetNames (.INFO), where he was a founding Board member of Afilias. Tom sold NetNames to NetBenefit, a public company on the London Stock Exchange and served on their Board of Directors.
Even earlier, Tom led the development of the SAEGIS trademark research platform for Thomson-CompuMark (now part of Clarivate), conducted business process re-engineering at Accenture and worked on jet engine factory automation for General Electric and Pratt & Whitney Aircraft. Tom has engineering degrees from MIT and WPI and lives north of Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Boyoung KIM
Boyoung KIM
Candidacy Statement | SOI I have been working at KISA as an international cooperation officer, participating in international meetings such as ICANN, IGF, etc to follow up the international issue and communicate with KISA and local community to improve the .kr ccTLD policy. Recently, I’ve been active as a board member of APTLD, contributing my experience to the Asia-pacific community. I am also involved in the Internet governance activities both locally and internationally. I have been deeply collaborating with DotAsia since 2016 through APIGA project. I have a thorough understanding of DotAsia’s youth initiative, NetMission ambassador. Also I served as the local secretariat when the APrIGF was hosted in Korea in 2014, so I am well acquainted with DotAsia’s APrIGF secretariat duties. As a member of the board, I want to contribute and ensure that the .asia TLD, which represents our region, is used for the benefits of our Internet community.Candidate BIO:
Name: Boyoung Kim Organization: Korea Internet & Security Agency(KISA) Job title: Deputy General Researcher Residence: Republic of Korea Boyoung Kim is in charge of domestic/international relations at KRNIC(Korea Network Information Center) of KISA(Korea Internet & Security Agency). Boyoung joined KISA in 2012 and since then has been involved in developing both domestic and international policy for domain name and Internet governance. She has been participating in ICANN as a GAC and ccNSO representative since 2012, which gave her sufficient knowledge on policy such as IANA transition(experienced IG structure development period), new gTLD policy, WHOIS/RDRS, RZ-LGR, etc. She shares her experience with local community to help them get involved in global policy development process. Also, she has been involved in several Internet Governance activities for the local and regional community. She hosted KrIGF for several years, APIGA(Asia Pacific Internet Governance Academy) since 2016, lead youth development projects such as IG curriculum, youth group, etc. Since she joined the APTLD as a board of director since 2021, tries to contribute to the AP community with her experience.DotAsia Board Elections 2024 – FAQ
Why are there multiple drafts of the Board Elections Procedures?
The first draft of the updated Board Elections Procedures (BEP)(BGC-004) for the Board Elections 2024 incorporates feedback from the observations raised previously, as well as edits in alignment with the Proposed Amendments to the DotAsia Articles of Association.
The second draft of the updated Board Elections Procedures (BEP)(BGC-004) for the Board Elections 2024 incorporates recommendations from the Election Committee (EC) Report on the Board Elections 2023 as well as comments received in response to the first draft.
Note also that there are 2 versions of the second draft posted:
- SECOND DRAFT-A anticipates that the proposed amendments to the DotAsia Articles are approved by Members
- SECOND DRAFT-B is a backup in the case that the proposed amendments are not approved by Members
The final draft of the updated Board Elections Procedures (BEP)(BGC-004) for the Board Elections 2024 is also posted in 2 versions:
- FINAL DRAFT-A anticipates that the proposed amendments to the DotAsia Articles are approved by Members
- FINAL DRAFT-B is a backup in the case that the proposed amendments are not approved by Members
The procedural aspects incorporated into both drafts are essentially the same (DRAFT-B does not include provisions for the Nomination Committee related processes which are to be introduced by the proposed amendments).
The final Board Elections Procedures (BGC-004 version 2) was posted on Feb 27, 2024 based on the FINAL DRAFT-A in accordance with the timeline and as a result of the Member adoption of the amended Articles of Association.
What was updated in Board Election 2024
Video replay of webinar conducted on March 28th, 2024 to present changes for Board Election 2024
If you can’t view the embedded video, click this link to view it in a separate browser window
What online voting platform will be used?
Big Pulse – https://www.bigpulsevoting.com/
Who can nominate/second or vote?
Nomination/Seconding:
In order to be eligible to propose or to second a nomination for a candidate, a Member must be
listed on the DotAsia website, at: http://www.dot.asia/dotasia-organisation/communitygovernance/ on or before the opening of the Nomination Period.
Voting:
In the case where voting is necessary, in order to be eligible to cast a ballot for the Board
Elections, a Member must be listed on the DotAsia website, at: http://www.dot.asia/dotasiaorganisation/community-governance/ on or before the opening of the Voting Period
In accordance to DotAsia Board Elections Procedure (BGC-004) section 2.1, Members must reply to both the Secretariat and the third-party Administrator to confirm or update the Voter Name and voting email address to be used. This confirmation must be received before the commencement of the Nomination Period.
If the Member does not confirm or update the Voter Name and the voting email address prior to the opening of the Nomination Period, they will not receive a nomination form or ballot paper, and may not nominate, second or vote in the election.
Voters list can also be found here: [ pdf ]
How do I vote?
- Eligible voters receive an invitation-to-vote email with a one-click link that automatically signs them into the ballot – the voters simply click and vote. After they cast their vote, the voters receive a confirmation email with a unique vote receipt. Please do not share this email.
- Upon voting, you will also receive an email from the Scrutineer to confirm your vote.
- Reply to the Scrutineer within the deadline listed in the email to complete the vote.
How do I verify my vote?
After you submit your vote you are issued a unique ‘Vote Receipt Code’, for each ballot that you vote in. The vote receipt code is shown on a secure webpage after you vote and is also emailed to you.
What do I do if I accidentally voted for the wrong candidate?
Contact the Election Compliance Administrator at boardelections@board.dot.asia
What happens in the case of an equality of votes?
The drawing of lots, if required, in the case of an equality of votes, will be carried out
automatically (algorithmically) and not manually by the voting platform.
What happens in case of technical issues during the voting period?
Under the Election Committee’s discretion, additional time may be afforded to cast votes.
What vote counting methods will be used?
First-past-the-post, (FPTP) also known as simple majority voting. The candidate with the most votes wins. However, please note that Geographical Diversity Requirement will be considered (refer to DotAsia Board Elections Procedures (BEP), Item 2.8).
Who can see my votes?
3rd Party Scrutineer, Election Committee and 3rd Party Election Compliance Administrator.
How does DotAsia comply with the Anti-Corruption law during the Board Election and what should I, as a voter, be aware of?
As a not-for-profit organization in Hong Kong, DotAsia follows the guidance of the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC). Specifically, the Best Practice Checklist – Governance and Internal Control in NGOs (Section 1.5) identifies the following for Nomination and Election of Board:
- Establish a mechanism for all Board members and voting members to nominate candidates for Board membership, in addition to those identified by the Nomination Committee
- Adopt an election procedure with adequate checks and balance to ensure fairness and transparency in the process (e.g. by requiring members to declare their relationship with the persons they are going to nominate and reminding members not to unduly influence other members’ nomination or election decisions).
DotAsia and its community reviews the DotAsia Board Elections Procedures (BEP) annually. The BEP identifies a clear process from nomination to voting. To ensure a fair and transparent process, third-party Election Committee members, Scrutineer and an Election Compliance Administration are invited to operate and monitor the Election.
As a voter, the ICAC wants to remind members NOT to unduly influence other members’ nomination or election decisions (such as soliciting, accepting or offering return of favor or personal gain)
DotAsia Board Elections 2025
DotAsia Election Code of Conduct (to be confirmed by NomCom 2025) Drafts: DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FIRST DRAFT (clean version) DotAsia Board Elections Procedures FIRST DRAFT (redline based on 2024 final version) Notice of DotAsia Board Elections 2025 FIRST...
DotAsia Board By-Election 2023
On November 6, 2023, the DotAsia Board, having received and reviewed the Election Committee (EC) Report to the Members DotAsia Regarding the 2023 Board Elections (EC Report) on November 1, 2023 accepted the report and proceeded to implement a By-Election for the...
DotAsia Board Elections 2023
On November 1, 2023, the Election Committee (EC) issued its Report to the Members DotAsia Regarding the 2023 Board Elections (EC Report). The EC Report confirms that, the DotAsia staff, the third party election provider, the election administrator and the Election...
DotAsia Annual General Meeting (AGM) Minutes May 23, 2024
Hybrid meeting 05.23.2024
DotAsia AGM 2024, Virtual
DotAsia Annual General Meeting, Virtual, 05.23.2024